It was August 1994, and a man named Stephen Earle was renovating a cottage in East Hampton. I was thirteen, growing up dead in the middle of the Midwest, and absolutely riveted.
I had discovered a wonderful magazine called Martha Stewart Living, which I used to sneak down to the local newsstand to buy. (Remember when you could go to a newsstand?) And there he was, in the pages of that magazine, choosing paint for his bedroom.
I remember reading the article, looking at the photographs, and imagining myself in that house. I studied the blue swatches and thought, Oh, I don’t quite like any of those. Then I wondered how you were supposed to make an adult decision like the correct blue for your bedroom, even with twelve helpful swatches.
Keep in mind that in 1994, in the middle of America, so much of what reached me about gay people seemed to come with fear, illness, or some sort of tragedy attached. The Real World was telling the story of Pedro Zamora, who spent the majority of his time on the show either yelling at roommates or talking about having AIDS. Tom Hanks was in Philadelphia and was facing discrimination and AIDS. Sex ed in school seemed to always come with a big side of, “Don’t do anything or you will get AIDS.” It was just a lot.
And to date, my only experience with a fellow was watching two seconds of one of the Baldwins fully naked in a movie called Sliver, which, if you haven’t seen it, really is a great film.
And then here was Stephen Earle in a beautiful house, taking the choice of bedroom blue very seriously.
My eyes kept returning to the portrait of him sitting on the windowsill of his under-construction home.
My God, he was handsome.
Ostensibly, I was thinking about the paint. But there were other things in the back of my brain that I knew I was eventually going to have to deal with. I just hadn’t gotten there yet.
Here was a glimpse of a life that I really wanted: a beautiful house, a lovely bedroom, the absolute luxury of being more than a little neurotic about the twelve shades of blue, and, if I’m being honest, Stephen Earle had some very distracting ankles.
P.S. At some point I folded down the corner of that magazine and put it in the nightstand drawer of my high-school bedroom. There it stayed until recently, when I was clearing the room out. I opened it again, looked at the photograph, and discovered that the lovely ankles of Mr. Earle still made me feel some feels.
P.P.S. Of all the opinions I held dear in 1994, most have fallen by the wayside or concern subjects I’ve since changed my mind about. Though I stand by my critique of the blues that Mr. Earle had picked out. None of them are quite right. And indeed, one of them looks like the color of a compact American car.